Peer Feedback Tool

It’s been my experience that kids hear teachers but listen to their peers. The smart teacher exploits this and makes peer review part of their classroom toolbox. 

The problem with peer review can be that it is sometimes hard to gather all of the feedback in one easy, accessible place. Reams of paper get “lost,” often in the round file. Handwriting can be hard to read. Some kids feel reluctant to write because of their spelling or writing skills.

I decided to try using microblogging to address these issues, and found that Wallwisher fit the bill nicely. It has several features that make it compliant with the KISS model:

It’s easy to set up and customize. As a teacher, you don’t even need an account to create a wall. You CAN sign up if you want more options and control.

There are no logins for students. Students simply log into the address of the wall you created, click their mouse, and begin microblogging. They can identify themselves by name, or remain anonymous.

There is no advertising. No links to redirect or annoying popups.

Here’s how I used it:

Wallwisher Sample

Peer Feedback from iMovie rough drafts. Click image to see actual wall

 

My students are working on iMovie projects. They have a rubric but they don’t often refer to it. Before final drafts were due, I created a wallwisher wall for each group and put the links on the classroom site. In class, I gave each student a copy of the rubric and a brief overview of what good feedback is- both positive and negative.

I also took the opportunity to discuss good digital citizenship with wallwisher. It is very easy for students to post anonymous comments of a nasty nature. We discussed the merits of good online behavior, then moved on to the directions for appropriate use of the tool.

As the presenting group got their laptop hooked to the projector, the rest of the class went to the “wall” and reviewed the rubric. Students watched the movie and provided feedback that was directly related to the video and the rubric- one comment positive feedback and one constructive critisism.  They were graded on the quality of their feedback to their peers. I added my own once students were finished.

Because student were limited to 160 characters, we talked about “txtng spllng”- that this was a time for content to trump conventions. The funny thing was, for the most part, they were interested in making their comments as understandable as possible.

Students now have a critique that they can use to improve their final draft. It’s in one place and easily accessible because it is linked to their classroom site. They also know “who said what” so that they can go to those students for either help or clarity. Engagement was high with this tool. We had 100% participation and very appropriate use. I highly recommend it.

Advertisements

4 responses to “Peer Feedback Tool

  1. What a great idea! I have been looking for various ways to use WallWisher. As a former 4th grade writing teacher, I understand how peer feedhack is important but can get out of hand. This seems like a much better way to handle it and engage the students. I love how feedback was related to the rubric (that teachers can take so much time to create and then students don’t really look at). I think limiting the amount of characters for the feedback makes students really concentrate on providing a clear message. Again, great idea!

  2. What a great idea! And thanks for embedding what it looked like – for a visual learner like me that helps!!

    I also loved that you included a little digital citizenship lesson – those are wonderful teaching moments and I always encourage teachers to do that when possible. I will use your example with them!!

  3. I Freaking Love It! My brain is at capacity with all of the ways I could use this program with my students. Your presentation approach was ingenious. I’m going to look at setting up my lessons to make that possible. Thanks for sharing!

    -@TheNerdyTeacher

  4. This is an outstanding use of Wallwisher, I hadn’t thought of using it for peer review. We do iMovies at the end of every year and, like your students, mine often fail to refer to the rubric. Getting peers involved is genius! Well done and thank you for sharing the idea with us!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s